To choose a marketing agency, start with the job you need done, then ask every agency on your list the same direct questions before you sign. Who will do the work? Who owns your ad accounts, website, and logins? How will they report results? What does the contract allow? Can they show similar work you can check for yourself? A good agency answers all of those plainly and puts the answers in writing.

We're an agency, so we have a stake in this. We've tried to write the guide we'd want a friend to read before hiring anyone, us included.

What Does a Marketing Agency Do?

A marketing agency plans and runs marketing for businesses that don't want to hire every skill themselves. The work usually falls into a few groups:

  • Strategy: deciding who you're trying to reach, where, and with what budget.
  • Content: photography, video, and social media posts.
  • Websites: design, building, hosting, and moving a site to a new platform.
  • Paid ads: Google Ads, plus social ads on Meta and other platforms.
  • Search: SEO, your Google Business Profile, and showing up in AI answers.
  • Email and print: newsletters, postcards, signs, and sales pieces.
  • Reporting: showing what the money and the work produced.

Some agencies do all of it. Others focus on one piece, like ads or video. Neither is better by default. A law firm that only needs Google Ads managed may be well served by a specialist. A contractor who needs photos, a new website, ads, and search work may prefer one team that can connect them. We're a full-service agency: one team handles social media, photo and video, websites, Google Ads, search, and email and print.

Ask each agency which parts it does itself and which parts it hands to someone else.

Agency vs In-House vs Freelancer

There's no single right answer. Each option fits a different kind of business.

An in-house marketer knows your business well, sits in your meetings, and can react the same day. The catch is that one person rarely covers video, ads, web development, and SEO equally well. You also pay for their tools and training, and the work stops when they're out or leave.

A freelancer brings one strong skill, usually with less overhead. A good freelance designer or ads specialist can be a great fit for a defined job. If you need several skills, though, you end up hiring and coordinating several freelancers yourself, and each one is a single point of failure.

An agency gives you several skills under one roof, with a process and backup when someone is out. The trade-off is that you share the team's attention with other clients, so you need to know who your contact is and how quickly they respond.

Many businesses mix in-house and agency help. An accounting firm might keep a marketing coordinator in-house who works with an agency for video, ads, and the website. That setup works well when both sides can see the same work. At two of the food halls we work with, each hall's marketing lead works on the same production board as our team and moves finished pieces to approved.

Before You Talk to Anyone

You'll get better answers if you know a few things first:

  • Your goal, in one sentence. More consultation calls for a law firm. More quote requests for a roofing company. More new clients before tax season for a bookkeeping firm.
  • A budget range for fees, and a separate one for ad spend.
  • Who approves work on your side, and how fast they can respond.
  • What you already have: the website, the logins, any ad accounts, photos, and past reports.

Questions to Ask Before You Sign

Who will actually do the work?

Ask for names and roles. Is any of the work passed to another company or done under someone else's label? Who is your day-to-day contact, and who is the senior person responsible for the account? At SXMG, Nick McElroy, who founded the company in 2021, leads every client relationship. Sebastián Cañón leads technology strategy, and a small team of editors and developers supports them, with specialists as needed.

Who owns the accounts, the website, and the content?

This question matters most on the day you leave. Ask about each item:

  • Ad accounts: are they in your business's name and billed to your card, or run inside the agency's own account?
  • Google Business Profile: you should be the owner, with the agency added as a manager.
  • Google Analytics and Search Console: set up under accounts you control.
  • Your domain: registered in your name.
  • Your website: who hosts it, and what you get if you move on.
  • Social media accounts and your email list.
  • Photos and video: what rights you have to use them after the contract ends.

Get the answers in writing. For our part, when we move a website we collect the domain, hosting, and site builder logins before work starts, and we set up analytics in accounts the business owns. Newsletters go out from the business's own Mailchimp, OpenTable, or Toast account.

How will you report results?

Ask which numbers you'll see, how often, and where they come from. A useful report ties the work to business results: calls, form fills, booked appointments, quote requests, sales. Impressions and follower counts are fine as background, but they shouldn't be the headline. Ask to see a sample report with the client's details removed.

Our monthly report is built around the measures each client asks for, with every figure taken from the platform that measures it. Google Ads accounts also get written reviews that list the changes step by step.

What does the contract say?

Read for length, notice period, and what happens to work in progress if you cancel. Check what's included and what costs extra. Ask how ad spend is billed and whether it's separate from the agency's fee. Ask how many rounds of changes are included and who pays for software. A proposal should set out the scope and the price in plain language before production begins.

How does approval work?

Will you see every post, ad, email, and page before it goes live? Where will you review it, and how fast do you need to respond? For regulated businesses this isn't optional. Law firms have state bar advertising rules. Medical practices have patient privacy rules. Financial firms have their own compliance reviews.

At SXMG, nothing goes out until you approve it. You review the work on a shared production board, a private preview link, a test send, or a proof.

Can you show similar work I can check?

Look for case studies that name the client, live websites you can visit, and reviews on Google. Similar work doesn't have to mean the same industry, but the agency should understand limits like yours. If you run a medical practice, ask how they've handled privacy in ads and reviews. Our healthcare marketing page is one example of what to look for: it names the Atlanta optometry practice we work with and explains what its ads do and don't track.

What happens in the first 90 days?

A good answer covers access, an audit, setup, and the first pieces of work, with realistic timing. Our new Google Ads campaigns, for example, run on a small budget for their first two weeks while Google learns which searches and ads work. Waiting on logins or content adds time, which is why we ask for access first.

Red Flags

  • Guaranteed rankings. Google's own guide to hiring an SEO warns that no one can guarantee a top spot. Our guide on how long SEO takes covers what's realistic.
  • Ad accounts, your domain, or your Business Profile held in the agency's name, with no access for you.
  • Long contracts with no way out, especially when the scope is vague.
  • Reports full of impressions and followers, with nothing about calls, leads, or sales.
  • No named people. You can't tell who is doing the work.
  • No live work to show, and no references.
  • Offers to buy followers or reviews, or to write reviews for you. The FTC bans fake reviews, and Google removes them.
  • Pressure to sign this week.

A Checklist for Your Shortlist

  • Named people who will do the work.
  • Ad accounts, Business Profile, analytics, and domain in your business's name.
  • A written answer on what happens to your website and content if you leave.
  • A sample report that shows business results.
  • A clear contract length, notice period, and list of what costs extra.
  • Your approval before anything goes live.
  • Similar work you can check, plus one reference you can call.

Common Questions

What does a marketing agency do for a small business?

It plans and runs the marketing you don't have time or staff for, such as social media, photos and video, websites, Google Ads, search, email, and print, and reports on what it produced.

Is it cheaper to hire in-house or use an agency?

It depends on how many skills you need. Compare the full cost of a hire, including salary, benefits, tools, and training, against an agency's fees for the same scope. If you need one skill every day, in-house often makes sense. If you need several skills part of the time, an agency often does.

How long should I give an agency before judging results?

It depends on the work. Ads usually show what they bring in within a couple of months. SEO takes longer, often several months. Ask the agency up front what you should see by month three.

Should I sign a long-term contract?

Only if you understand what you're getting and how to leave. A clear scope, a reasonable notice period, and accounts in your own name protect you more than any contract length.

If you're comparing agencies and want to put these questions to us directly, get in touch.